Most people, particularly the elderly, do not get enough calcium in their diets. Insufficient calcium may contribute to osteoporosis and high blood pressure. Dietary sources include dairy products, leafy green vegetables, and fish, but supplementary calcium tablets are often recommended as well. A bewildering number of preparations are available. Which one you should choose?
The first thing to know is that while it is the calcium that your body needs, the calcium always comes in combination with another substance, such as carbonate, citrate, lactate, or gluconate, which are technically known as calcium salts. Thus a 500 milligram (mg) Tums tablet, which consists of calcium carbonate, contains 200 mgs of calcium, the other 300 being carbonate. This distinction is important, because as shown in the table below, an 'Os-Cal 500' tablet has 1,250 mg of calcium carbonate, and 500 of calcium. And a 500 mg tablet of calcium gluconate contains only 45 mg of calcium. The table below shows some of the available preparations, including the dose, how much calcium each pill contains, and the cost (average wholesale price) for 500 mgs of calcium.
|
Calcium Salt |
Trade Name |
Dosage |
Calcium per tablet/capsule |
Cost for 500 mg calcium |
| Carbonate |
Tums | 500 mg tablet | 200 mg | 7 cents |
| Chooz |
500 mg tablet |
200 mg | 24 cents |
| Generic |
650 mg tablet |
260 mg | 3-18 cents |
| Tums E-X |
750 mg tablet |
300 mg | 7 cents |
| Alka-Mints | 850 mg tablet | 340 mg | 5 cents |
| Os-Cal 500 | 1,250 mg tablet | 500 mg | 11 cents |
| Caltrate 600 | 1,500 mg tablet | 600 mg | 9 cents |
| Citrate |
Citracal | 950 mg tablet | 200 mg | 17 cents |
| Lactate |
Generics | 325 mg tablet | 42 mg | 18-27 cents |
| Gluconate |
Generics | 500 mg tablet | 45 mg | 43-83 cents |
| |
975 mg tablet |
88 mg | 15-51 cents |
Another factor to consider is how well the different calcium salts are absorbed. In general, calcium citrate is absorbed a little better than calcium carbonate, but the differences are relatively small. Calcium supplements should be taken with food to maximize absorption.
Can you take too much calcium? Yes. The side effects of high doses of calcium are constipation, stomach bloating and excessive gas. More important is an increased risk of kidney stones.
Source: Marshall J. Calcium absorption and the choice of calcium supplements. Pharmacy & Therapeutics 1997;22:322.